That's Amore Italian Cafe

★★★★★
Enjoy Italian favorites in a traditional setting with a gorgeous view of the city at this Mount Baker hideaway.
  • 1425 31st Ave S

    Seattle, WA 98144

    Cross street: S Day Street

    Map & Directions
  • 206-322-3677

About That's Amore Italian Cafe

Hours
Sun 4pm-9pm, Mon-Thu 5pm-9pm, Fri-Sat 4pm-10pm

Food

Food
More choices in Seattle:
Resultset_next

Barolo Ristorante

1940 Westlake Ave Seattle, WA

Resultset_next

Madame K's Pizza Bistro

5327 Ballard Ave NW Seattle, WA

4.5 14
Hi! Sign in to let us know how That's Amore Italian Cafe was?
Write a Review
.

We held a wedding rehearsal dinner at That's Amore that was a big success. Chef Paul is a terrific cook and his staff were very congenial and attentive. We have received lots of compliments on the dinner and will visit the cafe

3
★★★★★

We held a wedding rehearsal dinner at That's Amore that was a big success. Chef Paul is a terrific cook and his staff were very congenial and attentive. We have received lots of compliments on the dinner and will visit the cafe

.

My husband and I went there for brunch around a month ago. We've been to this place twice before and were pretty satisfied overall. I am not sure what happened this time. May be the management changed...

The waiter was so rude, we could not believe it. He looked like he was doing us a huge favor by serving us. Never came to ask how the food was; did not refill tea pot; when asked why we had only 3 sausage links and not 4 as the menu showed, he did not answer and just went back to the kitchen with a face that we were asking to borrow a million $.....

The worst part of the brunch was that he brought us a debit card machine to our table. We had to swipe it at our table...while he was standing and watching....How bizzaire is that? Of course he got $0 as a tip. We are never going back to this place and telling our friends not to go there as well...

By the way, the place was empty when we came in and it was still empty when we left. Now we understand why!

0
★☆☆☆☆

My husband and I went there for brunch around a month ago. We've been to this place twice before and were pretty satisfied overall. I am not sure what happened this time. May be the management changed...

The waiter was so rude, we could not believe it. He looked like he was doing us a huge favor by serving us. Never came to ask how the food was; did not refill tea pot; when asked why we had only 3 sausage links and not 4 as the menu showed, he did not answer and just went back to the kitchen with a face that we were asking to borrow a million $.....

The worst part of the brunch was that he brought us a debit card machine to our table. We had to swipe it at our table...while he was standing and watching....How bizzaire is that? Of course he got $0 as a tip. We are never going back to this place and telling our friends not to go there as well...

By the way, the place was empty when we came in and it was still empty when we left. Now we understand why!

Pros: ok food

Cons: Horrible customer service

.

It's worth the drive to go to That's Amore. Though it's a wonderful neighborhood place, the quality of the food makes it a pleasure to bring friends.

Call ahead to reserve one of the view tables. It's a terrific angle on Seattle.

2
★★★★☆

It's worth the drive to go to That's Amore. Though it's a wonderful neighborhood place, the quality of the food makes it a pleasure to bring friends.

Call ahead to reserve one of the view tables. It's a terrific angle on Seattle.

Pros: Great Food, Great View

.

My wife and I tried this place and loved it. We will difinately be going back. The food, sefvice and view were terrific-just what we need to make it a great night. Try it ouT

2
★★★★★

My wife and I tried this place and loved it. We will difinately be going back. The food, sefvice and view were terrific-just what we need to make it a great night. Try it ouT

Pros: Food, View, Service

Cons: none

.

This resturant is a must. The food is sooooo good, and the atmosphere is wonderful. And to say nothing about the view would be awful. It is spectacular. Great place for out of town guests.

5
★★★★★

This resturant is a must. The food is sooooo good, and the atmosphere is wonderful. And to say nothing about the view would be awful. It is spectacular. Great place for out of town guests.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

.

My family and friends have all eaten at this great hidden gem of an Italian cafe over the years - we have never been disappointed! On one special occasion, Chef (and owner) Paul McMillion served our large group an incredible 'family style' Italian dinner - this was several years ago, and I still remember this divine meal! Scrumptious pasta, the steak with fresh tomato and wine sauce was especially good. Service has always been friendly and timely, ingredients are always great quality and fresh. My personal favorite is Chef Paul's unique take on Eggs Benedict, served over polenta. Every time I go for brunch now, I order this - each time it's just fabulous! Highly recommend this place, just wish there were more locations!

2
★★★★★

My family and friends have all eaten at this great hidden gem of an Italian cafe over the years - we have never been disappointed! On one special occasion, Chef (and owner) Paul McMillion served our large group an incredible 'family style' Italian dinner - this was several years ago, and I still remember this divine meal! Scrumptious pasta, the steak with fresh tomato and wine sauce was especially good. Service has always been friendly and timely, ingredients are always great quality and fresh. My personal favorite is Chef Paul's unique take on Eggs Benedict, served over polenta. Every time I go for brunch now, I order this - each time it's just fabulous! Highly recommend this place, just wish there were more locations!

Pros: BIG thumbs up! Amazing view, easy parking, love the outdoor seating in the summer

Cons: Sorry, no cons here . . .

.

They know their food here! I ate at That's Amore! with a group of friends on a summer evening. We enjoyed a beautiful evening sunset while mmmmmmming & oooohhing over the yummy food. It's a great place to go before a night out on the town in Downtown Seattle. If I lived closer, I would go there more often. I recommend this restaurant to my friends and family...I even take them there!

2
★★★★★

They know their food here! I ate at That's Amore! with a group of friends on a summer evening. We enjoyed a beautiful evening sunset while mmmmmmming & oooohhing over the yummy food. It's a great place to go before a night out on the town in Downtown Seattle. If I lived closer, I would go there more often. I recommend this restaurant to my friends and family...I even take them there!

Pros: Great ambience, delicious food, price is good, parking is not a problem

Cons: No bad experience here

.

We had dinner at That's Amore tonight based on some of the reviews here and my craving for Italian food. We were ?under-whelmed? to be honest. The staff was nice and we were seated right away (the place was pretty empty but we were early for a Friday night). The view of downtown is awesome.

The menu has a good selection and the prices are very reasonable. We did not have to wait too long for the food to be served and everything was hot. However, the food was simply bland - it wasn't bad but it wasn't great either. It basically tasted like nothing and that is pretty disappointing considering how flavorful good Italian food can be. We probably will not return to the restaurant other for having a glass of wine during a beautiful sunset evening.

1
★★★☆☆

We had dinner at That's Amore tonight based on some of the reviews here and my craving for Italian food. We were ?under-whelmed? to be honest. The staff was nice and we were seated right away (the place was pretty empty but we were early for a Friday night). The view of downtown is awesome.

The menu has a good selection and the prices are very reasonable. We did not have to wait too long for the food to be served and everything was hot. However, the food was simply bland - it wasn't bad but it wasn't great either. It basically tasted like nothing and that is pretty disappointing considering how flavorful good Italian food can be. We probably will not return to the restaurant other for having a glass of wine during a beautiful sunset evening.

Pros: Quick seating, kid friendly, great view

Cons: Bland food, drafty

.

The food is spectacular and the service is second to none. The menu is very broad appealing to everyone. Call in advance to reserve one of their window tables for an incredible sunset view over the city. That's Amore is a true neighborhood gem! Also an excellent place to take out of town guests.

2
★★★★★

The food is spectacular and the service is second to none. The menu is very broad appealing to everyone. Call in advance to reserve one of their window tables for an incredible sunset view over the city. That's Amore is a true neighborhood gem! Also an excellent place to take out of town guests.

.

I have experience several time the incredible food from That's Amore! and have not once been less than exctatic. The balance of flavors is,without reserve, the best I have had in Seattle; and I eat out daily [not at Taco Time or venues of similar nature]. The quality of ingredients is significantly above par [e.g. the tomatoes in the pasta salad, olives, and meats]. Presentation is incredible, as is service and value. I have yet to find a resturant in Seattle the can compare with the level of quality That's Amore! has to offer, combine with the value, which is incredible. The flavors of the dishes meld well together and compliment each other without over powering one another creating one of the most enjoyable eating experiences I have had yet. HIGHLY recommended.

2
★★★★★

I have experience several time the incredible food from That's Amore! and have not once been less than exctatic. The balance of flavors is,without reserve, the best I have had in Seattle; and I eat out daily [not at Taco Time or venues of similar nature]. The quality of ingredients is significantly above par [e.g. the tomatoes in the pasta salad, olives, and meats]. Presentation is incredible, as is service and value. I have yet to find a resturant in Seattle the can compare with the level of quality That's Amore! has to offer, combine with the value, which is incredible. The flavors of the dishes meld well together and compliment each other without over powering one another creating one of the most enjoyable eating experiences I have had yet. HIGHLY recommended.

Pros: Best Italian Food I have had, period.

Cons: none, eat here once and you will feel the same

.

Fantastic neighborhood joint. Great food, service, views, and beverages. They don't have to try hard because there's nothing else around, but they're consistently excellent on all counts.

2
★★★★★

Fantastic neighborhood joint. Great food, service, views, and beverages. They don't have to try hard because there's nothing else around, but they're consistently excellent on all counts.

Pros: food, location, service

Cons: crowded

.

Simple italian dishes with great class. This tiny place has amazing views of the city. Get a seat by the window and order an entree. The service is quick and friendly and you can linger for hours.

PROS: great views, great food
CONS: parking

4
★★★★☆

Simple italian dishes with great class. This tiny place has amazing views of the city. Get a seat by the window and order an entree. The service is quick and friendly and you can linger for hours.

PROS: great views, great food
CONS: parking

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

.

The food is so good and the staff is friendly. Call in advance for a window seat, there's a beautiful view of Seattle!

2
★★★★★

The food is so good and the staff is friendly. Call in advance for a window seat, there's a beautiful view of Seattle!

Pros: good food, nice view, friendly people

.

I have been here several times and have always been welcomed so nicely by the employees. Everything on the menu is delicious from the pizza to the pasta! Its a great place to sit down in or to order out from!

2
★★★★★

I have been here several times and have always been welcomed so nicely by the employees. Everything on the menu is delicious from the pizza to the pasta! Its a great place to sit down in or to order out from!

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used That's Amore Italian Cafe, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review