Casa Mia Italian Restaurant

★★★★☆
  • 505 N Meridian

    Puyallup, WA 98371

    Map & Directions
  • 253-770-0400

About Casa Mia Italian Restaurant

Hours
Sun 11am-8:30pm, Mon-Thu 11am-9pm, Fri-Sat 11am-10pm

Food

Food
More choices in Puyallup:
Resultset_next

Garlic Jim's Famous Gourmet

4621 S Meridian Puyallup, WA

Resultset_next

My Greek & Italian Restaurant

13333 Meridian E Puyallup, WA

4.0 10
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Casa Mia Italian Restaurant was?
Write a Review
.

Casa Mia is a fun informal Italian eatery. The pricing is reasonable and it is a friendly atmosphere. They sometimes have pretty good wait times, but expect to wait on the weekends. Try the pizza!

4
★★★★☆

Casa Mia is a fun informal Italian eatery. The pricing is reasonable and it is a friendly atmosphere. They sometimes have pretty good wait times, but expect to wait on the weekends. Try the pizza!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Casa Mia's is a great place. We usually get the pizza and the fettucine alfredo, and it's always really good. It's usually crowded and you have to wait a little bit, but it's worth it. The staff is very friendly, and the food is generally served quickly. The pricing is OK also.

4
★★★★☆

Casa Mia's is a great place. We usually get the pizza and the fettucine alfredo, and it's always really good. It's usually crowded and you have to wait a little bit, but it's worth it. The staff is very friendly, and the food is generally served quickly. The pricing is OK also.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

We love Casa Mia's. They are a cute little restaurant right in downtown Puyallup. They have very friendly staff, the food comes pretty quickly, and the atmosphere is very soothing!
They also have fast pick up and eat at home service with very generous portions. My kids love it!!

4
★★★★☆

We love Casa Mia's. They are a cute little restaurant right in downtown Puyallup. They have very friendly staff, the food comes pretty quickly, and the atmosphere is very soothing!
They also have fast pick up and eat at home service with very generous portions. My kids love it!!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I really had my hopes up for this place! Authentic it is not...the cheese pizza we ordered was horrible. It was flavorless and soggy! Cheese pizza is supposed to be slightly browned on the top...like it was actually baked in a wood-fired oven. The pasta sauce tastes like it came out of a very old can! The table was dirty and the server definitiely needed some customer service training. I just can't even begin to compare it to any authentic Italian restaurant...because it purely sucked! If you want good Pizza in Puyallup...go to Trackside!

0
★☆☆☆☆

I really had my hopes up for this place! Authentic it is not...the cheese pizza we ordered was horrible. It was flavorless and soggy! Cheese pizza is supposed to be slightly browned on the top...like it was actually baked in a wood-fired oven. The pasta sauce tastes like it came out of a very old can! The table was dirty and the server definitiely needed some customer service training. I just can't even begin to compare it to any authentic Italian restaurant...because it purely sucked! If you want good Pizza in Puyallup...go to Trackside!

Pros: Nada!

Cons: Everything

.

More than once have I driven a couple of hours to get take-out at Casa Mia (of which I waited all of 5 minutes to get my food!). I pretty much grew up on Casa Mia in Olympia (and rarely skip a chance to go there when I visit family) but my closest Casa Mia is Puyallup which is about an hours drive; that is when there is no traffic! Anyone who's been willing to go for the ride with me I've happily taken there, and I have yet to hear a complaint. I have very discriminating taste and Casa Mia is excellent! "True Italian" probably not, but the food is still excellent. The green salad (with the house italian dressing A MUST- they even bottle it it's so good) is superb- I like my salads simple so it works for me. The garlic bread- fabulous! The spaghetti w/marinara sauce- amazing! Meatball sandwiches- good! The prices are cheap. Not unusual to get dinner for 2 for $15 which is just about unheard of anymore, especially something that actually tastes good to boot! I was surprised by the comments that Casa Mia is romantic and/or non-family. I think the it's the total opposite...great for families and kids and not a very romantic spot (might slightly differ per location). The staff has always been friendly, especially at the Puyallup location. Oh, and that dressing I mentioned? I always have a bottle at home since no other bottled viniagrette even comes close, especially at around $2.50 a bottle, and it's even been requested by out of state relatives as gifts! I've said it for years and will hopefully for many more...my all time favorite restaurant is Casa Mia!

2
★★★★★

More than once have I driven a couple of hours to get take-out at Casa Mia (of which I waited all of 5 minutes to get my food!). I pretty much grew up on Casa Mia in Olympia (and rarely skip a chance to go there when I visit family) but my closest Casa Mia is Puyallup which is about an hours drive; that is when there is no traffic! Anyone who's been willing to go for the ride with me I've happily taken there, and I have yet to hear a complaint. I have very discriminating taste and Casa Mia is excellent! "True Italian" probably not, but the food is still excellent. The green salad (with the house italian dressing A MUST- they even bottle it it's so good) is superb- I like my salads simple so it works for me. The garlic bread- fabulous! The spaghetti w/marinara sauce- amazing! Meatball sandwiches- good! The prices are cheap. Not unusual to get dinner for 2 for $15 which is just about unheard of anymore, especially something that actually tastes good to boot! I was surprised by the comments that Casa Mia is romantic and/or non-family. I think the it's the total opposite...great for families and kids and not a very romantic spot (might slightly differ per location). The staff has always been friendly, especially at the Puyallup location. Oh, and that dressing I mentioned? I always have a bottle at home since no other bottled viniagrette even comes close, especially at around $2.50 a bottle, and it's even been requested by out of state relatives as gifts! I've said it for years and will hopefully for many more...my all time favorite restaurant is Casa Mia!

Pros: Great food, service, prices

Cons: None except I wish there were one closer!

.

Ick! I have had a few items on their menu and was not pleased. The pizza is ok at best, but this is a typical small town restaurant...not authentic Italian at all. No full flavors, spices or fresh ingredients. Everything is covered up by cheese. If you have nowhere else to eat and live in the area, it's ok, but not good.

1
★★☆☆☆

Ick! I have had a few items on their menu and was not pleased. The pizza is ok at best, but this is a typical small town restaurant...not authentic Italian at all. No full flavors, spices or fresh ingredients. Everything is covered up by cheese. If you have nowhere else to eat and live in the area, it's ok, but not good.

Pros: Nice service, Cheap

.

Absolutely without a doubt the best kept secret around. The best pizza and spaghetti with meat sauce I've had in a resaurant. My husband and I were shocked. We drove by it all of the time. That won't happen much anymore.

2
★★★★★

Absolutely without a doubt the best kept secret around. The best pizza and spaghetti with meat sauce I've had in a resaurant. My husband and I were shocked. We drove by it all of the time. That won't happen much anymore.

Pros: Food, Service, Family Setting

Cons: Small

.

This wonderful little restaraunt offers a warm and cozy atmosphere with wonderful service and even better food. Their chicken and three cheese pizza is the best I have ever tasted! Delivery doesn't compare once you've tried it. I think their salad leaves a bit to be desired but my husband adores it. I would highly recommend Casa Mia to anyone looking for a nice quiet place to dine.

2
★★★★★

This wonderful little restaraunt offers a warm and cozy atmosphere with wonderful service and even better food. Their chicken and three cheese pizza is the best I have ever tasted! Delivery doesn't compare once you've tried it. I think their salad leaves a bit to be desired but my husband adores it. I would highly recommend Casa Mia to anyone looking for a nice quiet place to dine.

Pros: Food!!!, Service, Atmosphere

.

Lovely romantic getaway. I've been here several times. The salad is always wonderfully minimalistic, with few unnecessary additions (only lettuce, cheese, black olives and dressing), but large in portion. Sodas come served in large carafes, which is a nice change from the norm. Overall, one restaurant I will return to again and again! I have taken children here before and had no problems, but it's not Chucky Cheese, thank God!

2
★★★★★

Lovely romantic getaway. I've been here several times. The salad is always wonderfully minimalistic, with few unnecessary additions (only lettuce, cheese, black olives and dressing), but large in portion. Sodas come served in large carafes, which is a nice change from the norm. Overall, one restaurant I will return to again and again! I have taken children here before and had no problems, but it's not Chucky Cheese, thank God!

Pros: Garlic chicken pizza!, Tortellini!

Cons: Parking, Not the best for kids

.

I read the review from the man about taking his family there. It is clearly not a family restraunt I agree. It is a very romantic and quiet setting. The first time I was there I was completely impressed by the food and the service. The cook especially! Maybe this man went there on a bad night, because I have grown up with a mother who was taught to cook by Italians, and mmmmm, their food is, how do you say, squisito! (Meaning delicious)
Anyone with children, this is definately not the setting you are looking for... couples looking for a nice dinner out? Perfetto! Perfect!

2
★★★★★

I read the review from the man about taking his family there. It is clearly not a family restraunt I agree. It is a very romantic and quiet setting. The first time I was there I was completely impressed by the food and the service. The cook especially! Maybe this man went there on a bad night, because I have grown up with a mother who was taught to cook by Italians, and mmmmm, their food is, how do you say, squisito! (Meaning delicious)
Anyone with children, this is definately not the setting you are looking for... couples looking for a nice dinner out? Perfetto! Perfect!

Pros: Inexpensive, Great quanities, Romantico

Cons: Poor parking

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Casa Mia Italian Restaurant, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review