Post Alley Pizza

★★★★☆
  • 1123 Post Ave

    Seattle, WA 98101

    Map & Directions
  • 206-382-8475

About Post Alley Pizza

Hours
Monday-Friday 11a.m.-7p.m.

Food

Food
More choices in Seattle:
Resultset_next

Pagliacci Pizza Restaurant & Delivery - Broadway

426 Broadway Ave. E. Seattle, WA

Resultset_next

Pagliacci Pizza: Queen Anne

550 Queen Anne Ave N Seattle, WA

3.9 20
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Post Alley Pizza was?
Write a Review
.

You have got to get off the sofa and visit Post Ally....The pizza chef is awesome. Real people minded and likes to give each pizza a special touch! He's real edgy and is also a musician...Check him out!

2
★★★★★

You have got to get off the sofa and visit Post Ally....The pizza chef is awesome. Real people minded and likes to give each pizza a special touch! He's real edgy and is also a musician...Check him out!

Pros: Custom Pizzas and a Gifted Musician!

.

Please disregard my previous comment. I was commenting on another pizza place and realized that I clicked on the wrong pizza place. I have never been to Post Alley Pizza and apologize for the mishap.

2
★★★★★

Please disregard my previous comment. I was commenting on another pizza place and realized that I clicked on the wrong pizza place. I have never been to Post Alley Pizza and apologize for the mishap.

.

I dont know why people are so crazed about this pizza place. The pizza that i ordered was extremely greasy and the quality of the ingredients are poor. I'll stick with my neighborhood's Pagliacci's instead in U. District!

1
★★☆☆☆

I dont know why people are so crazed about this pizza place. The pizza that i ordered was extremely greasy and the quality of the ingredients are poor. I'll stick with my neighborhood's Pagliacci's instead in U. District!

.

This was the best pizza I have had in years. Yum yum. The owners are so nice and friendly. It was so good that we had them make pizzas for our new company's presentation. We couldn't stop eating.

1
★★★☆☆

This was the best pizza I have had in years. Yum yum. The owners are so nice and friendly. It was so good that we had them make pizzas for our new company's presentation. We couldn't stop eating.

.

This pizza is sooooo good! I'm picky when it comes to finding a good pizza joint since I'm not the biggest fan of some of the cheap stuff that is served around my neighborhood but this definitely has the "New York Authenticity" to go along with quick service that's helpful when grabbing a bite to eat on a lunch break. While I'm a bit hesitant to write good reviews of the places I enjoy eating at (since it contributes to the place becoming overcrowded and popular) I'd feel guilty keeping such a find all to myself. Enjoy!

1
★★★☆☆

This pizza is sooooo good! I'm picky when it comes to finding a good pizza joint since I'm not the biggest fan of some of the cheap stuff that is served around my neighborhood but this definitely has the "New York Authenticity" to go along with quick service that's helpful when grabbing a bite to eat on a lunch break. While I'm a bit hesitant to write good reviews of the places I enjoy eating at (since it contributes to the place becoming overcrowded and popular) I'd feel guilty keeping such a find all to myself. Enjoy!

.

While PAP has decent pizza, I certainly do not think it is the best, but at $2 a slice you cannot beat it. There are all kinds of different pizza and I hate it when people try to compare varities, but here are my favs; Greek=Pegasus, light crusts, great Greek toppings and a killer location on Alki Beach, Sicillian=Abbondonza, thin chewy crusts and great toppings make go back over and over again, New York=Paggliacci get a Queens pepperoni and meatballs...MMM.

2
★★★★☆

While PAP has decent pizza, I certainly do not think it is the best, but at $2 a slice you cannot beat it. There are all kinds of different pizza and I hate it when people try to compare varities, but here are my favs; Greek=Pegasus, light crusts, great Greek toppings and a killer location on Alki Beach, Sicillian=Abbondonza, thin chewy crusts and great toppings make go back over and over again, New York=Paggliacci get a Queens pepperoni and meatballs...MMM.

Pros: Price

Cons: Slow and not much seating

.

Post Alley is the only real pizza joint in this city by eastcoast standards...too unclean...shut-up, this is a pizza shop...people use their hands, make dough, cut lettuce etc. go somewhere else, and bring some cleaning solution...and the idiot going by macorpheuspora...go eat the glue dough up at Via Tribunali like all the other pizza morons in this city...twit

2
★★★★★

Post Alley is the only real pizza joint in this city by eastcoast standards...too unclean...shut-up, this is a pizza shop...people use their hands, make dough, cut lettuce etc. go somewhere else, and bring some cleaning solution...and the idiot going by macorpheuspora...go eat the glue dough up at Via Tribunali like all the other pizza morons in this city...twit

Pros: damn fine pizza

Cons: stupid customers that don't get it

.

Post Alley has great pizza, the sauce is homemade (VERY YUM) and the crust is just slightly burnt/toasty, if you like that, which I do. However, they are always out of pepperoni or pizza by the slice altogether resulting in long waits, which isn't good on people's limited lunch hour. The shop is DIRTY with UNCLEAN food preparation. They do not wash the romaine for their cesar salad. When the bin isn't stocked, they just pull out the romain, chop it, and use it, again no washing. The counters are dirty and the crew will often touch people's money and then touch your food as well. Besides being unclean, the largest gripe is how unorganized this place is. If the food wasn't so as good as it is, I wouldn't go back.

1
★★★☆☆

Post Alley has great pizza, the sauce is homemade (VERY YUM) and the crust is just slightly burnt/toasty, if you like that, which I do. However, they are always out of pepperoni or pizza by the slice altogether resulting in long waits, which isn't good on people's limited lunch hour. The shop is DIRTY with UNCLEAN food preparation. They do not wash the romaine for their cesar salad. When the bin isn't stocked, they just pull out the romain, chop it, and use it, again no washing. The counters are dirty and the crew will often touch people's money and then touch your food as well. Besides being unclean, the largest gripe is how unorganized this place is. If the food wasn't so as good as it is, I wouldn't go back.

Pros: Homeade Sauce, Good Crust, Savory

Cons: Unclean, Unorganized, Frequently out of Pepperoni Pizza

.

I stayed for about 6 weeks at Harbor Steps and during this time I've got pizza from them a couple of times. Well, I didn't like it. If possible, is worse than the frozen pizza you get from the grocery store. But the one from Post Alley is more expensive. the thin pizza is usually soggy- if you have the bad idea to ask for tomatoes and/or mushrooms as your toppings. You can find better. Or you can give it a try, maybe you'll be luckier than I was

PROS: good service
CONS: bad pizza

3
★★★☆☆

I stayed for about 6 weeks at Harbor Steps and during this time I've got pizza from them a couple of times. Well, I didn't like it. If possible, is worse than the frozen pizza you get from the grocery store. But the one from Post Alley is more expensive. the thin pizza is usually soggy- if you have the bad idea to ask for tomatoes and/or mushrooms as your toppings. You can find better. Or you can give it a try, maybe you'll be luckier than I was

PROS: good service
CONS: bad pizza

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I live in Minnesota and I was visiting my brother in Seattle for spring break and my wife and I were downtown in search of a place to eat. We took a shotcut and saw the pizza shop and went in. I found the Pizza to be the best I have ever had and very good price. We ate for under $10. I love the place so much I insist that ever time or ANY family goes they must stop in for a meal. I love the mood and is a great getaway from the drizzle.

2
★★★★★

I live in Minnesota and I was visiting my brother in Seattle for spring break and my wife and I were downtown in search of a place to eat. We took a shotcut and saw the pizza shop and went in. I found the Pizza to be the best I have ever had and very good price. We ate for under $10. I love the place so much I insist that ever time or ANY family goes they must stop in for a meal. I love the mood and is a great getaway from the drizzle.

Pros: Inexpensive, friendly, few seats

.

ok i just got here from new york and regardless of what the very few neg. reviews say (you obviously appreciate domino's, zeek's, or pagliachi's over real pizza) POST ALLEY is the best pizza Seattle has offer. everything about this place, the staff, the sauce, crust, etc. is amazing. too bad its only open on the weekdays. try it!

2
★★★★★

ok i just got here from new york and regardless of what the very few neg. reviews say (you obviously appreciate domino's, zeek's, or pagliachi's over real pizza) POST ALLEY is the best pizza Seattle has offer. everything about this place, the staff, the sauce, crust, etc. is amazing. too bad its only open on the weekdays. try it!

Pros: pepperoni, sauce, crust

.

Our office tried (twice) this pizza vendor due to the reviews we saw on this site. We ordered two pizza's each time. We were disappointed in the both times. Nothing fun about these "pies". Crust is flavorless and toppings are sparse. Ratings of the other pizza locations were, however, right on.

1
★★☆☆☆

Our office tried (twice) this pizza vendor due to the reviews we saw on this site. We ordered two pizza's each time. We were disappointed in the both times. Nothing fun about these "pies". Crust is flavorless and toppings are sparse. Ratings of the other pizza locations were, however, right on.

Pros: ready on time

Cons: flavorless, sparse toppings, flat tasting crust

.

No, this is definitely the real northeast style pizza, like in every small-town joint from Pittsburgh to Boston. It's pretty good, too, and it's the best one for 2000 miles around if you've got the jonesing for a slice.

2
★★★★★

No, this is definitely the real northeast style pizza, like in every small-town joint from Pittsburgh to Boston. It's pretty good, too, and it's the best one for 2000 miles around if you've got the jonesing for a slice.

Pros: Cheap, Delicious, Authentic

Cons: Small, No delivery

.

Some of the worst pizza in Seattle. Paper thin, never fresh, and overpriced.

1
★★☆☆☆

Some of the worst pizza in Seattle. Paper thin, never fresh, and overpriced.

.

This was one of the worst pieces of pizza I've had in Seattle. I come from NY/NJ and there are only three decent pizza places in Seattle. This is not one of them.

0
★☆☆☆☆

This was one of the worst pieces of pizza I've had in Seattle. I come from NY/NJ and there are only three decent pizza places in Seattle. This is not one of them.

.

I have to eat my own words in another review about NY style Pizza in Seattle. Post Alley has it, so go get it!! It's definitely the CRUST and the sauce is just right ! The pepperoni slices kick *ss!

2
★★★★★

I have to eat my own words in another review about NY style Pizza in Seattle. Post Alley has it, so go get it!! It's definitely the CRUST and the sauce is just right ! The pepperoni slices kick *ss!

Pros: the crust the crust !, the sauce the sauce !, the staff the staff !

Cons: only open M-F, parking not easy

.

Food and environment here rivals the best I've seen in NYC itself (and that's where I live...So I should know!).

Even plain slice (best indicator of good pizzeria) is DELICIOUS (perfectly spiced). Service superb and great prices. It's a 10!

2
★★★★★

Food and environment here rivals the best I've seen in NYC itself (and that's where I live...So I should know!).

Even plain slice (best indicator of good pizzeria) is DELICIOUS (perfectly spiced). Service superb and great prices. It's a 10!

.

This is BY FAR the best pizza in town!!! Post Alley Pizza's food, staff, and Mom and Pop management make for an exceptional visit every time. And to think there's only one location!!! The pizza itself is to die for - especially nights when Katie is cooking!!! Keep up the good work! Jeff Seattle, WA

2
★★★★★

This is BY FAR the best pizza in town!!! Post Alley Pizza's food, staff, and Mom and Pop management make for an exceptional visit every time. And to think there's only one location!!! The pizza itself is to die for - especially nights when Katie is cooking!!! Keep up the good work! Jeff Seattle, WA

Pros: Great Prices, Yummy Pizza, Super-friendly staff

Cons: Only ONE Location

.

Jonesing for a New York-style slice? Post Alley knows how to make pizza and other Italian food the way it was meant to be served. Do yourself a favor and try the real deal.

2
★★★★★

Jonesing for a New York-style slice? Post Alley knows how to make pizza and other Italian food the way it was meant to be served. Do yourself a favor and try the real deal.

Pros: prompt, delicious, excellent service

.

as good a pizza pie as you'll find anywhere - from Boston to the samoan islands. good times and definitely damn good food.

2
★★★★★

as good a pizza pie as you'll find anywhere - from Boston to the samoan islands. good times and definitely damn good food.

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Post Alley Pizza, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review