Simma's

★★★★☆
  • 817 N 68TH St

    Milwaukee, WI 53213

    Map & Directions
  • 414-257-0998

About Simma's

Hours
Tue - Fri, 7am - 6pm; Sat, 7am - 5pm; Sun, 8am - noon; Mon, closed

Food

Food
More choices in Milwaukee:
Resultset_next

Balistreri's Italian-American

812 N 68th St Milwaukee, WI

Resultset_next

Conejito's Place

539 W Virginia St. Milwaukee, WI

4.3846 13
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Simma's was?
Write a Review
.

I think the title says it all! I've been fortunate to enjoy their selections for years and am never disappointed.

5
★★★★★

I think the title says it all! I've been fortunate to enjoy their selections for years and am never disappointed.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Some time back I special ordered 12 key lime tarts, as they don't usally have them already made. I have had them in the past and they were wonderful. I drove 40 mins one way to come and get them. When I arrived, they spent about 20 mins running all over only to come back and say they sold them to someone else. The girl just stared at me. After about 15 seconds I asked 'what are we going to do about this?' She then told me that they would give me 1/2 off on anything I wanted.

????????

Now why would I want something else, when I ordered key lime tarts you might ask? Good question. I left.
I then wrote a nice complaint letter and they mailed me a gift certicicate for $25. NOW, the tarts are about $3 a piece. 12 tarts I origianally ordered at $3 a piece comes to about $38 with the tax ( not calculating my gas and my time). I sent the gift cert. back explaining this and they never responded again and kept the gift cert.

WTF???

NEXT, my nephew wanted his cake to come from Simma's, as he was at my wedding 3 years ago and that is what I had. I went 6-8 weeks ago and ordered the cheesecake, which was good, except the cake on the bottom was a bit dry. I ordered a sheet cake for the 'grooms cake'.

IT WAS F***ING HORRIBLE! THE FONDIT WAS CHEWY, BUT WORSE THE CAKE WAS SO DRY, NO ONE ATE IT. WE THREW IT IN THE TRASH!

I am throughly DISGUSTED by the lack of quality (service and product) that I will go out of my way to tell people NOT to use Simma's. Many of their products are really good, but they need to be ALL GOOD. After spending way over $1,000 I expect if to be at least edible.

Shame on me for trying them again thinking something would change after my first crappy encounter.

GO SOMEWHERE ELSE, ANYWHERE!

0
★☆☆☆☆

Some time back I special ordered 12 key lime tarts, as they don't usally have them already made. I have had them in the past and they were wonderful. I drove 40 mins one way to come and get them. When I arrived, they spent about 20 mins running all over only to come back and say they sold them to someone else. The girl just stared at me. After about 15 seconds I asked 'what are we going to do about this?' She then told me that they would give me 1/2 off on anything I wanted.

????????

Now why would I want something else, when I ordered key lime tarts you might ask? Good question. I left.
I then wrote a nice complaint letter and they mailed me a gift certicicate for $25. NOW, the tarts are about $3 a piece. 12 tarts I origianally ordered at $3 a piece comes to about $38 with the tax ( not calculating my gas and my time). I sent the gift cert. back explaining this and they never responded again and kept the gift cert.

WTF???

NEXT, my nephew wanted his cake to come from Simma's, as he was at my wedding 3 years ago and that is what I had. I went 6-8 weeks ago and ordered the cheesecake, which was good, except the cake on the bottom was a bit dry. I ordered a sheet cake for the 'grooms cake'.

IT WAS F***ING HORRIBLE! THE FONDIT WAS CHEWY, BUT WORSE THE CAKE WAS SO DRY, NO ONE ATE IT. WE THREW IT IN THE TRASH!

I am throughly DISGUSTED by the lack of quality (service and product) that I will go out of my way to tell people NOT to use Simma's. Many of their products are really good, but they need to be ALL GOOD. After spending way over $1,000 I expect if to be at least edible.

Shame on me for trying them again thinking something would change after my first crappy encounter.

GO SOMEWHERE ELSE, ANYWHERE!

Pros: Great cheescake

Cons: Order? You ordered something? Oh, sorry, we forgot.

.

The best pastries - taste, appearance - one of a kind! We love it. If you want to impress friends and family, take them something from Sima's and watch their faces. It's worth it.

2
★★★★★

The best pastries - taste, appearance - one of a kind! We love it. If you want to impress friends and family, take them something from Sima's and watch their faces. It's worth it.

.

The cheesecake is wonderful, as well as all the other baked goods. Simma's has perfected its style of cheesecake and compliments it with fillings, rather than flavored cheesecake. The PRESENTATION divine - you couldn't present anything more beautiful than one of their cheesecakes or desserts.

5
★★★★★

The cheesecake is wonderful, as well as all the other baked goods. Simma's has perfected its style of cheesecake and compliments it with fillings, rather than flavored cheesecake. The PRESENTATION divine - you couldn't present anything more beautiful than one of their cheesecakes or desserts.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Can't go wrong here. We have used Simma's for both weddings and birthdays and have never been disappointed. Everyone always wants to know where we get the cheesecake from. In addition to cheesecake, there is also a nice selection of other bakery items for purchase.

5
★★★★★

Can't go wrong here. We have used Simma's for both weddings and birthdays and have never been disappointed. Everyone always wants to know where we get the cheesecake from. In addition to cheesecake, there is also a nice selection of other bakery items for purchase.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I got my sons graduation cake here. They did a great job decorating it and everyone at the party couldn't get enough. My daughter came for some late at night and I have to laugh at her when she asked if there was some still left to eat.

5
★★★★★

I got my sons graduation cake here. They did a great job decorating it and everyone at the party couldn't get enough. My daughter came for some late at night and I have to laugh at her when she asked if there was some still left to eat.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Besides walking in during the week and finding delectable treats to eat, for your next party or wedding, order a cake or torte from Simma's! The tortes are out of this world and you can never go wrong. The hardest part is making up your mind which torte to order.

The cakes are moist and so scrumptious! The frosting of your choice is not overly sweet, but compliments the choice of cake you made.

During the winter, it can be nice to stop in and have a great, steaming cup of good coffee along with one of the bakery eats on display. If you are fortunate, there may be a chair to sit in while enjoying the entreating aromas of the homemade bakery.

2
★★★★★

Besides walking in during the week and finding delectable treats to eat, for your next party or wedding, order a cake or torte from Simma's! The tortes are out of this world and you can never go wrong. The hardest part is making up your mind which torte to order.

The cakes are moist and so scrumptious! The frosting of your choice is not overly sweet, but compliments the choice of cake you made.

During the winter, it can be nice to stop in and have a great, steaming cup of good coffee along with one of the bakery eats on display. If you are fortunate, there may be a chair to sit in while enjoying the entreating aromas of the homemade bakery.

Pros: Great bakery, great people, the best Tortes

Cons: Not enough areas to sit if you just want to drop in and try some treat

.

OUTSTANDING! Birthdays, weddings, retirements, engagements, holidays....whatever the occassion and whatever your taste, they have something for you.

An extra plus for this place is that this is the only bakery I know of in the city that combines regular cake and cheesecake in 2-3 layers of decadense.

Try It.....no diets here.

5
★★★★★

OUTSTANDING! Birthdays, weddings, retirements, engagements, holidays....whatever the occassion and whatever your taste, they have something for you.

An extra plus for this place is that this is the only bakery I know of in the city that combines regular cake and cheesecake in 2-3 layers of decadense.

Try It.....no diets here.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

For every birthday, wedding, baby shower and wedding shower in the last 20 years - my family has ordered a Simma's cheesecake. They are beautiful as well as tasty. You'll never get a better cheesecake! Wedding displays are amazing. You can even get a slice if you don't want a whole cake. I have recommended Simma's to anyone who is asking about wedding cakes or any dessert needed for anything. They will decorate something on the spot for you too!

5
★★★★★

For every birthday, wedding, baby shower and wedding shower in the last 20 years - my family has ordered a Simma's cheesecake. They are beautiful as well as tasty. You'll never get a better cheesecake! Wedding displays are amazing. You can even get a slice if you don't want a whole cake. I have recommended Simma's to anyone who is asking about wedding cakes or any dessert needed for anything. They will decorate something on the spot for you too!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Cakes, goodies, oh my, too much to describe. I have really never tasted anything better than the treats that come from Simmas. This is DEF. worth the money, even if you are paying a little more. And it is DEF. worth the drive if you're not in the area.

The bakeries found in this place are truly a masterpiece and delicious. They decorate cakes the way you want them, and the staff is just great. I HIGHLY recommend Simmas. Please, go NOW, you will NOT regret it!

PROS: EVERYTHING!
CONS: NOTHING!

5
★★★★★

Cakes, goodies, oh my, too much to describe. I have really never tasted anything better than the treats that come from Simmas. This is DEF. worth the money, even if you are paying a little more. And it is DEF. worth the drive if you're not in the area.

The bakeries found in this place are truly a masterpiece and delicious. They decorate cakes the way you want them, and the staff is just great. I HIGHLY recommend Simmas. Please, go NOW, you will NOT regret it!

PROS: EVERYTHING!
CONS: NOTHING!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

The breakfast and pecan rolls are fabulous. The cakes are great and the cheesecake is heavenly. Quick pick up service and nice staff. Single servings available too.

5
★★★★★

The breakfast and pecan rolls are fabulous. The cakes are great and the cheesecake is heavenly. Quick pick up service and nice staff. Single servings available too.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Simma's is the place in the Milwaukee area to get a cheesecake - they are creamy, smooth and delicious. You can buy the cakes at the store or order them ahead for pick up. You can get them plain or chocolate-covered, and I believe with various fillings. They also make all kinds of cakes and tortes. And they have a great assortment of various baked goods and sweets; and I think carry Breadsmith bread.

You can eat there or take out, but I believe most people take out since their dining area is very small and just the front waiting area of the store.

PROS: Delicious Cheesecakes and other desserts!
CONS: Too small

5
★★★★★

Simma's is the place in the Milwaukee area to get a cheesecake - they are creamy, smooth and delicious. You can buy the cakes at the store or order them ahead for pick up. You can get them plain or chocolate-covered, and I believe with various fillings. They also make all kinds of cakes and tortes. And they have a great assortment of various baked goods and sweets; and I think carry Breadsmith bread.

You can eat there or take out, but I believe most people take out since their dining area is very small and just the front waiting area of the store.

PROS: Delicious Cheesecakes and other desserts!
CONS: Too small

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Never tried their cheesecake but trying to order a wedding cake from them was a headache!!!!! None of them knew the answer to anything and when they asked someone else...they would come back with the wrong information. I would find this out at my finalization appointment where I thought I could get all the exact information I needed. The person who helped us couldn't answer anything. She couldn't even give us suggestions when we asked for them. Ended up not being helpful at all but incredibly rude!!!!!! Not only that but she made us feel as if we were in the wrong and was hardly apologetic.....Even when we found out the cake sizes (we were told we could order) were given to us wrong.....thus making the price of the cake much more expensive than anticipated. We're not picky or demanding at all but we had to bail on this place.

0
★☆☆☆☆

Never tried their cheesecake but trying to order a wedding cake from them was a headache!!!!! None of them knew the answer to anything and when they asked someone else...they would come back with the wrong information. I would find this out at my finalization appointment where I thought I could get all the exact information I needed. The person who helped us couldn't answer anything. She couldn't even give us suggestions when we asked for them. Ended up not being helpful at all but incredibly rude!!!!!! Not only that but she made us feel as if we were in the wrong and was hardly apologetic.....Even when we found out the cake sizes (we were told we could order) were given to us wrong.....thus making the price of the cake much more expensive than anticipated. We're not picky or demanding at all but we had to bail on this place.

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Simma's, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review