Johnny Manhattan's

★★★★★
  • 3718 Hubertus Rd

    Hubertus, WI 53033

    Map & Directions
  • 262-628-7700

Food

Food
More choices in Hubertus:
Resultset_next

Seigos Japanese Steak House

N64 W23180 Main Street Sussex, WI

Resultset_next

Ponderosa Steakhouse

1285 E Sumner St Hartford, AL

4.5455 22
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Johnny Manhattan's was?
Write a Review
.

Best place to eat love it tell all my friends. Love the filet soup and salad potatoes great friendly waitstaff. Clean restrooms. Must have escargot and crab cakes. Friend had prime rib. Let me tell you melted in his mouth great place

3
★★★★★

Best place to eat love it tell all my friends. Love the filet soup and salad potatoes great friendly waitstaff. Clean restrooms. Must have escargot and crab cakes. Friend had prime rib. Let me tell you melted in his mouth great place

.

We went for the Friday fish fry. We ordered a couple of drinks, the crab cakes and two fish fries. The server brings the drinks with the salad selections. Before we could taste the salads or sip our drinks another server dropped off the

3
★★★★★

We went for the Friday fish fry. We ordered a couple of drinks, the crab cakes and two fish fries. The server brings the drinks with the salad selections. Before we could taste the salads or sip our drinks another server dropped off the

.

We went on a Saturday night and the drive there was beautiful. It is a quaint little steak house in the Holy Hill area which is warm and inviting and cozy. Our waitress was exceptional and had us laughing all through dinner and all the

3
★★★★★

We went on a Saturday night and the drive there was beautiful. It is a quaint little steak house in the Holy Hill area which is warm and inviting and cozy. Our waitress was exceptional and had us laughing all through dinner and all the

.

1st off the owner was VERY friendly w/my date...would not even acknowledge me....HELLO...there are two of us! (rude) The salad average, crabcakes...below average, the crab mushroom soup...my advice....pass on this, it was more of a "DIP" than soup....mind you i do not like watered down soup, but this was not soup....would be great as an appetizer served w/crackers. We both agreed that the mashed potatoes were more of something you'd get from an "Applebee's"
If you like medium/rare steak...stay clear from the garlic stuffed filet....total disapointment.....it was served medium well. Quality of food, not that of a finer restaurant....we will NOT be going back there!!

0
★☆☆☆☆

1st off the owner was VERY friendly w/my date...would not even acknowledge me....HELLO...there are two of us! (rude) The salad average, crabcakes...below average, the crab mushroom soup...my advice....pass on this, it was more of a "DIP" than soup....mind you i do not like watered down soup, but this was not soup....would be great as an appetizer served w/crackers. We both agreed that the mashed potatoes were more of something you'd get from an "Applebee's"
If you like medium/rare steak...stay clear from the garlic stuffed filet....total disapointment.....it was served medium well. Quality of food, not that of a finer restaurant....we will NOT be going back there!!

.

OMG Ate there for the first time about 6 months ago and was very impressed with the food and the service was fantastic. Can't get a better steak anywhere. Priced right.........including soup & salad. We keep going back,once a week, we love it, recommend it to everyone.

2
★★★★★

OMG Ate there for the first time about 6 months ago and was very impressed with the food and the service was fantastic. Can't get a better steak anywhere. Priced right.........including soup & salad. We keep going back,once a week, we love it, recommend it to everyone.

Pros: Great Steaks

Cons: Parking occassionally

.

Too smoky... Bar smoke filters to dining area. Needs exhaust badly. See you in June 2010 when the smokefree law sets in.

1
★★☆☆☆

Too smoky... Bar smoke filters to dining area. Needs exhaust badly. See you in June 2010 when the smokefree law sets in.

.

We've been there several times and have always had a great meal. Friday nights can be very busy so we pass on that evening. My husband always orders the steaks and they're de-lish. Bar is a bit smokey for me.

2
★★★★☆

We've been there several times and have always had a great meal. Friday nights can be very busy so we pass on that evening. My husband always orders the steaks and they're de-lish. Bar is a bit smokey for me.

.

I was recently in Hubertus and stumbled across this gem. Gem not so much. We were greeted by the hostess who seemed frazzled. The atmosphere was of a beat down supper club. My gut told me to walk out however, we stayed. Big mistake we both had the Friday night fish fry. It tasted like the fish was fried hours prior then reheated in the microwave. The server was friendly. The kicker was when it came time to pay we were told by the server that we could't pay on separate charges. That the owner did not allow this. Come to find out the owner was the "frazzeled" hostess. Unbelievable! Next time I will go with my gut feeling and run!

0
★☆☆☆☆

I was recently in Hubertus and stumbled across this gem. Gem not so much. We were greeted by the hostess who seemed frazzled. The atmosphere was of a beat down supper club. My gut told me to walk out however, we stayed. Big mistake we both had the Friday night fish fry. It tasted like the fish was fried hours prior then reheated in the microwave. The server was friendly. The kicker was when it came time to pay we were told by the server that we could't pay on separate charges. That the owner did not allow this. Come to find out the owner was the "frazzeled" hostess. Unbelievable! Next time I will go with my gut feeling and run!

Pros: Holy Hill is close by.

.

MY HUSBAND TOOK ME OUT FOR OUR ANNIVERSARY, GREAT SERVICE, FRIENDLY, NICE ATMOSPHERE AND GREAT FOOD. WE PLAN ON COMING BACK SOON! WE HAVE ALSO RECOMMENDED IT TO ALOT OF PEOPLE SINCE WE ATE THERE. I HAVE NEVER DONE A REVIEW, BUT THIS PLACE IS WORTH THE TIME.

2
★★★★★

MY HUSBAND TOOK ME OUT FOR OUR ANNIVERSARY, GREAT SERVICE, FRIENDLY, NICE ATMOSPHERE AND GREAT FOOD. WE PLAN ON COMING BACK SOON! WE HAVE ALSO RECOMMENDED IT TO ALOT OF PEOPLE SINCE WE ATE THERE. I HAVE NEVER DONE A REVIEW, BUT THIS PLACE IS WORTH THE TIME.

.

I have eaten at Johnny Manhattan's on a few occasions (all on Friday nights) and can tell you their "all you can eat" fish fry is well worth the trip. OUTSTANDING potato pancakes and a choice of baked or fried fish makes for a FULL dinner. I did have the 1/2 rack of BBQ ribs on one visit and those, too, were outstanding. Definitely a place to check out.

4
★★★★☆

I have eaten at Johnny Manhattan's on a few occasions (all on Friday nights) and can tell you their "all you can eat" fish fry is well worth the trip. OUTSTANDING potato pancakes and a choice of baked or fried fish makes for a FULL dinner. I did have the 1/2 rack of BBQ ribs on one visit and those, too, were outstanding. Definitely a place to check out.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Best steak, for the best price anywhere, try the large Filet you won't be disappointed. Friendly, good service each time we visit.

2
★★★★★

Best steak, for the best price anywhere, try the large Filet you won't be disappointed. Friendly, good service each time we visit.

Pros: prompt seating

.

My husband and I have been dining at Johnny's for five years. We have visited many other restaurants in the Milwaukee and also the Washington county area. NO ONE compares! Their food is OUTSTANDING! Johnny and Nancy couldn't be better hosts & their staff is always friendly and very helpful. I HIGHLY recommend this restaurant. You will NOT be dissapointed! We Love Johnny Manhattan's !!

2
★★★★★

My husband and I have been dining at Johnny's for five years. We have visited many other restaurants in the Milwaukee and also the Washington county area. NO ONE compares! Their food is OUTSTANDING! Johnny and Nancy couldn't be better hosts & their staff is always friendly and very helpful. I HIGHLY recommend this restaurant. You will NOT be dissapointed! We Love Johnny Manhattan's !!

.

Johnny Manhattan's is everything you're looking for in a fine dining restaurant. The owners John and Nancy walk around the whole place, stopping to talk to many customers, making sure everyone's enjoying themselves. I felt like family at Johnny's and their steaks are OUTSTANDING. I highly recommend this place.

2
★★★★★

Johnny Manhattan's is everything you're looking for in a fine dining restaurant. The owners John and Nancy walk around the whole place, stopping to talk to many customers, making sure everyone's enjoying themselves. I felt like family at Johnny's and their steaks are OUTSTANDING. I highly recommend this place.

.

Nancy and Johnny are wonderful people - we rarely go out to eat anywhere else. There food is the best!!!!

2
★★★★★

Nancy and Johnny are wonderful people - we rarely go out to eat anywhere else. There food is the best!!!!

.

This restaurant is the "ONE AND ONLY" Not only are the steaks the greatest, but also everything else that they serve. The service is fantastic ! The hosts Nancy and Johnny are marvelous. Their wonderful personalities have given us the greatest and most pleasurable dining experience!

2
★★★★★

This restaurant is the "ONE AND ONLY" Not only are the steaks the greatest, but also everything else that they serve. The service is fantastic ! The hosts Nancy and Johnny are marvelous. Their wonderful personalities have given us the greatest and most pleasurable dining experience!

.

Prime rib is excellent...the best I've had!!!! Great time to go is around Christmas. The decorations are unbelievable!!! And the service, so very polite. If you haven't tried it, make an effort to stop in!

2
★★★★★

Prime rib is excellent...the best I've had!!!! Great time to go is around Christmas. The decorations are unbelievable!!! And the service, so very polite. If you haven't tried it, make an effort to stop in!

.

I have enjoyed each visit to Johnny Manhattan's. My favorites are the Pork Chops and the New York Strip, my wife orders the Friday Fish Fry and the Veal dishes. Service from the time we arrrive to leaving has been outstanding. It is refreshing to recieve personalized attention at a busy restaurant....Thanks to the staff at Johnny's for caring about your customers.

2
★★★★★

I have enjoyed each visit to Johnny Manhattan's. My favorites are the Pork Chops and the New York Strip, my wife orders the Friday Fish Fry and the Veal dishes. Service from the time we arrrive to leaving has been outstanding. It is refreshing to recieve personalized attention at a busy restaurant....Thanks to the staff at Johnny's for caring about your customers.

.

Yum, loved the ribs. Service is friendly. Overall good experience.

2
★★★★★

Yum, loved the ribs. Service is friendly. Overall good experience.

.

We were greeted at the door by a friendly gentleman, who we were informed later was the owner. This made us most welcome. Our table was ready in a very short amount of time...Our waitress was pleasant and very attentive. Our party of six had excellent food varying from baked fish,ribs and filets.We continued to feel welcome and in no way felt "rushed". Great dinner!

2
★★★★★

We were greeted at the door by a friendly gentleman, who we were informed later was the owner. This made us most welcome. Our table was ready in a very short amount of time...Our waitress was pleasant and very attentive. Our party of six had excellent food varying from baked fish,ribs and filets.We continued to feel welcome and in no way felt "rushed". Great dinner!

Pros: Value, Ambiance, Friendly

.

We went to Johnny's and had a excellent meal, everything from soups to salads, very very good . Steaks are great , prime rib is good. You walk in the place and its like stepping back in time, very nice. Price was reasonable, Highly Recommened !

2
★★★★★

We went to Johnny's and had a excellent meal, everything from soups to salads, very very good . Steaks are great , prime rib is good. You walk in the place and its like stepping back in time, very nice. Price was reasonable, Highly Recommened !

.

I live near Johnny Manhattan's and go there often. They have great food, great Bavarian Weissbier and the owners are very friendly people. I would recommend a visit to anyone.

2
★★★★★

I live near Johnny Manhattan's and go there often. They have great food, great Bavarian Weissbier and the owners are very friendly people. I would recommend a visit to anyone.

.

I had dinner there the other night, great food,
in a warm cozy atmosphere. I can't wait to go back. I hear from others the Fish Fry is to die for
on Friday nights.

2
★★★★★

I had dinner there the other night, great food,
in a warm cozy atmosphere. I can't wait to go back. I hear from others the Fish Fry is to die for
on Friday nights.

Pros: great food, fair prices, relaxed atmosphere

Cons: parking

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Johnny Manhattan's, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review