Mama De Marinis

★★★★☆
42.9997 -87.8915
Map and Directions to Mama De Marinis Pizza-Bay View

414-481-1770

2457 S Wentworth Ave

Milwaukee, WI

53207

Get Directions

About Mama De Marinis

Food

Food
More choices in Milwaukee:
Resultset_next

Ned's Pizza

3246 S 27TH St Milwaukee, WI

Resultset_next

Pizza Shuttle

1827 N Farwell Ave Milwaukee, WI

4.3846154 13
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Mama De Marinis was?
Write a Review
Reviews 1 - 13 of 13.
.

Was there in June 2011. Pizza was the best I've ever eaten, nice crisp crust and the toppings were loaded. The italian sausage sandwich was hand formed seasoned meat, which you could tell was made from scratch and was flavorful and excellent. The staff was friendly and treated you as if you were family, and the atmosphere was welcoming and fun. It was a good value, and I will certainly return again and again.

5
★★★★★

Was there in June 2011. Pizza was the best I've ever eaten, nice crisp crust and the toppings were loaded. The italian sausage sandwich was hand formed seasoned meat, which you could tell was made from scratch and was flavorful and excellent. The staff was friendly and treated you as if you were family, and the atmosphere was welcoming and fun. It was a good value, and I will certainly return again and again.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Went to Mama's in I think October, never again. My kids wanted a cheese pizza. They burnt the first one, crust and cheese, I would have been embarrassed to bring it out, it looked like a black pancake. Asked if it was "OK", I said no, they started a new pizza already knowing I would not accept it.

Second Pizza, Burnt again but not as bad, they blamed it on the kids ordering a cheese pizza and they are hard to make without burning so they would not make another. Are you kidding me?? My older daughter ate the least burnt piece and my younger refused. Waitress asked if she should wrap it up, I told her they can throw it away here.

They only charged me 1/2 for the burnt pizza. And she pleaded that we come back another time as we were leaving.

I used to go there as a kid but never again.

2
★★☆☆☆

Went to Mama's in I think October, never again. My kids wanted a cheese pizza. They burnt the first one, crust and cheese, I would have been embarrassed to bring it out, it looked like a black pancake. Asked if it was "OK", I said no, they started a new pizza already knowing I would not accept it.

Second Pizza, Burnt again but not as bad, they blamed it on the kids ordering a cheese pizza and they are hard to make without burning so they would not make another. Are you kidding me?? My older daughter ate the least burnt piece and my younger refused. Waitress asked if she should wrap it up, I told her they can throw it away here.

They only charged me 1/2 for the burnt pizza. And she pleaded that we come back another time as we were leaving.

I used to go there as a kid but never again.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

0 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

.

the service here is good. the food is average. The resturant is kid friendly but the bar is in the middle so on a busy night it can be smokey. You can us your entertainment coupon here.

3
★★★☆☆

the service here is good. the food is average. The resturant is kid friendly but the bar is in the middle so on a busy night it can be smokey. You can us your entertainment coupon here.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Some of the best old world style pizza available in Milwaukee!!! The pizzas here are served in square pans just like back in the old country! Service is great, but bear in mind that this is a neighborhood favorite, and a short wait may be in order. The eggplant is good, and garlic bread authentic. Enjoy!!

5
★★★★★

Some of the best old world style pizza available in Milwaukee!!! The pizzas here are served in square pans just like back in the old country! Service is great, but bear in mind that this is a neighborhood favorite, and a short wait may be in order. The eggplant is good, and garlic bread authentic. Enjoy!!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

Latest reviews from Citysearch.

.

I can still rememeber how it smells. My folks started ordering from Mama in the 1960's and continued until they retired from the Milwaukee area. It was always a treat to know that we were going to have this pizza for supper. I used to love it even cold with a big glass of milk. It is hard to find a place these days that uses canned mushrooms on their pizza, it just seems wrong to put fresh ones on it. I have been living in Louisville, Kentucky for 10 years now and still have not found anything that pales in comparison to De Marini's. You folks back home in Milwaukee be thankful this great pizza place is there. Enjoy !!

5
★★★★★

I can still rememeber how it smells. My folks started ordering from Mama in the 1960's and continued until they retired from the Milwaukee area. It was always a treat to know that we were going to have this pizza for supper. I used to love it even cold with a big glass of milk. It is hard to find a place these days that uses canned mushrooms on their pizza, it just seems wrong to put fresh ones on it. I have been living in Louisville, Kentucky for 10 years now and still have not found anything that pales in comparison to De Marini's. You folks back home in Milwaukee be thankful this great pizza place is there. Enjoy !!

Pros: Great food, Great atmosphere, I loved the bayview area.

Cons: parking can be a problem when very busy

.

I grew up in this restaurant. My father used to bring the family then I worked in the kitchen in my teens. Heck, we even adopted one of the owners dogs years ago. The pizza here is the best anywhere especially if you like sausage which is made exclusivly for De Marinis from the family recipe. The cheese is also a special treat which is put on in slices rather than shredded which allows for more uniform coverage. The sauage sandwich is also to awsome.

5
★★★★★

I grew up in this restaurant. My father used to bring the family then I worked in the kitchen in my teens. Heck, we even adopted one of the owners dogs years ago. The pizza here is the best anywhere especially if you like sausage which is made exclusivly for De Marinis from the family recipe. The cheese is also a special treat which is put on in slices rather than shredded which allows for more uniform coverage. The sauage sandwich is also to awsome.

Pros: Food, ambiance and service

Cons: Can get busy but well worth the wait.

.

I remember the first time I ate this pizza, It was like God's gift to pizza's, then I ate it again and it was not so good and even ate it a few times after that to the point where it was disgusting, I had problems with the pizza being over cooked, under cooked, lack of ingredients and then at times it would taste like it was sitting around for weeks before they prepared it, I would not recommend this place to anyone.

2
★★☆☆☆

I remember the first time I ate this pizza, It was like God's gift to pizza's, then I ate it again and it was not so good and even ate it a few times after that to the point where it was disgusting, I had problems with the pizza being over cooked, under cooked, lack of ingredients and then at times it would taste like it was sitting around for weeks before they prepared it, I would not recommend this place to anyone.

Pros: They got TV

Cons: too many to mention

.

Neither New York or Chicago have anything this good. Not anything near as good. Mama's sausage is still be best on the planet. Mama has the leg up on her sons in consistancy. Her pies are always perfect, never burned or raw. Close attention is paid to what comes out of her kitchen. It's a taste that is unmatched.

Now if I could only convince mom and pop DiMarini to move down here to the Tampa Bay area and start making their Pizza's in Clearwater! Then God would be being very very good to me and the rest of the folks here. We only have BAD pizza here. It's sad when the best pizza in town is Domino's!

5
★★★★★

Neither New York or Chicago have anything this good. Not anything near as good. Mama's sausage is still be best on the planet. Mama has the leg up on her sons in consistancy. Her pies are always perfect, never burned or raw. Close attention is paid to what comes out of her kitchen. It's a taste that is unmatched.

Now if I could only convince mom and pop DiMarini to move down here to the Tampa Bay area and start making their Pizza's in Clearwater! Then God would be being very very good to me and the rest of the folks here. We only have BAD pizza here. It's sad when the best pizza in town is Domino's!

Pros: Always the best pizza anywhere

Cons: They need a bigger place

.

I was introduced(indoctrinated) to De Marinis early on by Mom and Dad who went there when they were dating(50"s). The crust is perfect. The toppings are the best in taste and size. Dine in or take out you can't beat it. I take many out of town guests to De Marini's and when they are planning to come back to town; they make me promise to return. My favorite CSM-extra cheese.

5
★★★★★

I was introduced(indoctrinated) to De Marinis early on by Mom and Dad who went there when they were dating(50"s). The crust is perfect. The toppings are the best in taste and size. Dine in or take out you can't beat it. I take many out of town guests to De Marini's and when they are planning to come back to town; they make me promise to return. My favorite CSM-extra cheese.

Pros: Never met anyone that did not love it!

Cons: none

.

I WILL NEVER GO ANYWHERE TO ORDER PIZZA AGAIN DE MARINIS IS THE BEST PIZZA ANYWHERE- I ALWAYS GET A LARGE SAUSAGE PIZZA W/EXTRA SAUSAGE AND IT'S GREAT :)
GREAT PRICES, VERY NICE PEOPLE, NICE ENVIRONMENT ( I WISH THE PLACE WAS BIGGER)
A++++++++++++++

5
★★★★★

I WILL NEVER GO ANYWHERE TO ORDER PIZZA AGAIN DE MARINIS IS THE BEST PIZZA ANYWHERE- I ALWAYS GET A LARGE SAUSAGE PIZZA W/EXTRA SAUSAGE AND IT'S GREAT :)
GREAT PRICES, VERY NICE PEOPLE, NICE ENVIRONMENT ( I WISH THE PLACE WAS BIGGER)
A++++++++++++++

Pros: THE BEST PIZZA IN THE WORLD AND EXCELLENT SPEED SERVICE

Cons: I WISH THE PLACE WAS BIGGER AND THEY EXPANDED TO OAK CREEK

.

my grandfather, my dad, myself and now my sons have enjoyed this restaurant for many years. I live in Phoenix now but if you're lucky to have a relative living in Milwaukee as I do...there is nothing like begging them to ship a "half-baked" across the country for our eating pleasure though there is nothing quite like the atmosphere of the restaurant itself. This is by far the best pizza in Brew Town!

5
★★★★★

my grandfather, my dad, myself and now my sons have enjoyed this restaurant for many years. I live in Phoenix now but if you're lucky to have a relative living in Milwaukee as I do...there is nothing like begging them to ship a "half-baked" across the country for our eating pleasure though there is nothing quite like the atmosphere of the restaurant itself. This is by far the best pizza in Brew Town!

Pros: just the aroma when you get within 6 blocks is enough to get you in the door

Cons: can be busy on Fri/Sat but still worth the wait :-)

.

I have been eating at this location for 40+ years, my brother has 50+ under his belt, and my parents have been eating there since the mid 1950's, Although there was some early quality issues in the late 1980's from feuding siblings, Mama Demarinis has stayed with the original proportions of toppings, and the flavor is almost exactly what I have craved whenever Demarinis is mentioned. The sausage is the best I have ever had, For a short while I tried the other place just up the road, (Dom & Phils) just to be disappointed. So I got used to ordering double sausage on my pizza, Please do not make that mistake at Mama's unless you realy love sausage. There was so much sausage we could not see any other topping including the cheese (it was great though)

5
★★★★★

I have been eating at this location for 40+ years, my brother has 50+ under his belt, and my parents have been eating there since the mid 1950's, Although there was some early quality issues in the late 1980's from feuding siblings, Mama Demarinis has stayed with the original proportions of toppings, and the flavor is almost exactly what I have craved whenever Demarinis is mentioned. The sausage is the best I have ever had, For a short while I tried the other place just up the road, (Dom & Phils) just to be disappointed. So I got used to ordering double sausage on my pizza, Please do not make that mistake at Mama's unless you realy love sausage. There was so much sausage we could not see any other topping including the cheese (it was great though)

Pros: Nothing has changed, excellent food, excelent pricing

.

This was absolutly the best pizza I have enjoyed for a long long time. From the time I entered the door and was warmly greeted to the friendly bartender who served me a good joke along with a cold brew. My waitess Marilyn was the most outstanding waitress there could be. Quick, friendly and very good. What else can I say. Oh, except that the aroma of the restaurant would be to die for. It rReally made me anticipate the fabulous pizza that I was waiting for. I can say no more. they are the best!!

5
★★★★★

This was absolutly the best pizza I have enjoyed for a long long time. From the time I entered the door and was warmly greeted to the friendly bartender who served me a good joke along with a cold brew. My waitess Marilyn was the most outstanding waitress there could be. Quick, friendly and very good. What else can I say. Oh, except that the aroma of the restaurant would be to die for. It rReally made me anticipate the fabulous pizza that I was waiting for. I can say no more. they are the best!!

Pros: taste, atmosphere, friendlieness

Similar Nearby

Similar Nearby

  1. 1
    0.10 mi
  2. 2
    Pietro's Pizza
    4% ★★★★☆ 3 reviews
    0.59 mi
  3. 3
    Topper's Pizza
    1% ★☆☆☆☆ 1 review
    0.70 mi
  4. 4
    Francisco's Pizza
    No reviews
    0.90 mi
  5. 5
    Pizza Hut
    5% ★★★★★ 2 reviews
    0.94 mi