Jimmy's Grotto

Hands down one of the best pizza places in waukesha. The sausage has an authentic taste and the crust is one of a kind. Also if you haven't had a ponza rotta, you should try it and see what you're missing out on. Original to Waukesha since 1946!

After waiting over a hour for my delivery. My wife noticed her chicken sand. wasn't fully cooked. Called a told them and they were happy to send out a new one. After hanging up the phone I cut into my Ponza and noticed the meat was missing. After another call to the store I was told they will send it right out with the chicken sand. BUT, I would have to pay .75 cents for the extra topping. HELLO? You screwed up and I have to pay? Its now been over a hour and Im still waiting for my food. Ive been eating your food for many years. You have now lost all my business over .75 cents.

I have not been there for some time, but they still have good pizza

They have the best food I ever had.they have a deep fryed pizza pocket that u can have with any topping that comes on a pizza and ever time plus they have a good staff of workers.if u haven't tryed jimmys grotto u have to u won't be disappointed

Pros: All I have to say is deep fryed pizza pocket

The food is great if you love that kind of greasy heart stopping deep fried calzone thing. I like it on ocasion. The service has always been good for me. I have always noticed that when i order pizzas and ponza's that it seems to end up with some ingredients i didn't order in it. Typically a couple onions and what not seem to get in the mix all and all I don't mind its something everyone should try at least once.

Pros: delicous in that disgusting kind of way

Cons: dont expect to much its pretty straight forward.

we were told our order would arrive in an hour-IT DIDN'T.we called back 75 min. later and were told it was on the road.
we ordered from this place because one of our friends told us how great it was.we ordered a large pizza-garlic cheese bread and deep fried mushrooms.the pizza arrived cold as well as the cheese bread and the mushrooms were soggy.our bill was $32.00.we called to complain and were offered a $15.00 credit. when we paid the delivery driver $35.00 she said thanks and left and when we asked for our change she gave us $2.00 and left.so she cheated us out of a dollar.I would have happily let the driver keep the tip if it would have been delivered within the promised hour considering we only live at the most 15 min away.
then when we cashed in our $15.00 credit we ordered two cod dinners and again we were VERY disappointed. the food again arrived cold and was the worst fish dinner i have ever tasted.
IT WILL BE A COLD DAY in hell before I ever order anything from this place AGAIN.!!!

Pros: pizza was ok

Cons: slow delivery-cold pizza-and soggy deep fried mushrooms