Tony's Pizza

★★★★☆

About Tony's Pizza

Hours
Sun 1pm-2:30am, Mon-Sat 11am-3am

Food

Food
More choices in Shepherdstown:
Resultset_next

Domino's Pizza

502 Williamsport Pike Martinsburg, WV

Resultset_next

Domino's Pizza

65 D Cordial Court Falling Waters, WV

3.6667 3
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Tony's Pizza was?
Write a Review
.

It cracks me up to hear Tony's Pizza reviewed as a dining establishment. The food (although delicious) is only secondary to the spirits served downstairs. Tony's is the only place in town that caters to the college drinking crowd. Although family friendly during the day, the pizza serves as a drunk broke college kid's best friend. The person below reviewing the service was obviously mistaken about how service at Tony's works. Most locals know to just walk up to the counter, place your order, choose your seat, and if you are lucky and the girls aren't slammed upstairs, then they will be nice enough to bring it to the table. Its a pizza joint, with a roudy bar in the basement ..What do you expect? It also happens to be one of my favorite establishments in town other than my own!
I personally reccommend the Captain and coke! LoL

5
★★★★★

It cracks me up to hear Tony's Pizza reviewed as a dining establishment. The food (although delicious) is only secondary to the spirits served downstairs. Tony's is the only place in town that caters to the college drinking crowd. Although family friendly during the day, the pizza serves as a drunk broke college kid's best friend. The person below reviewing the service was obviously mistaken about how service at Tony's works. Most locals know to just walk up to the counter, place your order, choose your seat, and if you are lucky and the girls aren't slammed upstairs, then they will be nice enough to bring it to the table. Its a pizza joint, with a roudy bar in the basement ..What do you expect? It also happens to be one of my favorite establishments in town other than my own!
I personally reccommend the Captain and coke! LoL

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I had just moved to the area and took a couple of visiting friends there on a Friday evening for dinner. The place was not filled as we did not have trouble finding an open table. We waited for more than 15 minutes just to get a menu, and then only after we asked for one. The drinks took about that long as well. The menu was great and the prices were pretty good. We placed our order only after our waitress gave us 3 minutes to look over the menu. She was very rude and did not offer any evidence that she had an ounce of courtesy. While we waited for our food, we tried to signal to the waitress for a refill, and even though she clearly noticed our attempt to get her attention, she ignored us. When our food was ready, she came to our table without saying a word, reached in front of me and my friends to grab the pizza shelf, and slammed our pizza down and walked away.
When we were finished, we waited another 20 minutes to get the bill, but only after we went to the counter to ask for it. Needless to say we did not leave a tip. I hope this was an isolated incident. I will try again and hope for improvement.

1
★☆☆☆☆

I had just moved to the area and took a couple of visiting friends there on a Friday evening for dinner. The place was not filled as we did not have trouble finding an open table. We waited for more than 15 minutes just to get a menu, and then only after we asked for one. The drinks took about that long as well. The menu was great and the prices were pretty good. We placed our order only after our waitress gave us 3 minutes to look over the menu. She was very rude and did not offer any evidence that she had an ounce of courtesy. While we waited for our food, we tried to signal to the waitress for a refill, and even though she clearly noticed our attempt to get her attention, she ignored us. When our food was ready, she came to our table without saying a word, reached in front of me and my friends to grab the pizza shelf, and slammed our pizza down and walked away.
When we were finished, we waited another 20 minutes to get the bill, but only after we went to the counter to ask for it. Needless to say we did not leave a tip. I hope this was an isolated incident. I will try again and hope for improvement.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.

.

We discovered Tony's Pizza, when my sister attended Shepherd College 18 years ago. Back then it was called Stonewalls, but the Pizza and Subs are still just as good today. Now we take the kids there. The subs, calazones and stomboli are too large for one person to eat, we always share. The medium pizza is large enough for 5 kids to share. They also have Italian dishes, if you hunger for something more.

During Late Spring to Early Fall, the garden behind the restuarant is nice place to eat Al Fresco.

Gena N

5
★★★★★

We discovered Tony's Pizza, when my sister attended Shepherd College 18 years ago. Back then it was called Stonewalls, but the Pizza and Subs are still just as good today. Now we take the kids there. The subs, calazones and stomboli are too large for one person to eat, we always share. The medium pizza is large enough for 5 kids to share. They also have Italian dishes, if you hunger for something more.

During Late Spring to Early Fall, the garden behind the restuarant is nice place to eat Al Fresco.

Gena N

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Tony's Pizza, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review