Fehn's Cake & Cookie Shop

★★★★☆
  • 3649 Merrick Rd

    Seaford, NY 11783

    Map & Directions
  • 516-785-2253

About Fehn's Cake & Cookie Shop

Categories
Hours
Mon, closed; Tue - Thu, 6:30am - 7pm; Fri, Sat, 6am - 7pm; Sun, 6am - 6pm

Food

Food
More choices in Seaford:
Resultset_next

Station 7 Restaurant

10912 County Seat Hwy Laurel, DE

Resultset_next

Seaford Eagle Diner

23412 Sussex Hwy Seaford, DE

3.5 4
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Fehn's Cake & Cookie Shop was?
Write a Review
.

Maybe I'm spoiled but growing up with Gerst's was an incredibly wonderful memory. Moved away 18 yrs ago and got to go back last week. On top of my list was a shopping spree at Gerst's, now Fehn's. I read reviews before I went and was concerned but decided to try it anyway. Apple Strudel was good but at $9 per LB it better be. I've had better. Irish soda bread had way too much fennel seed and the rest of it was nothing special. The donuts had a good amount of jelly and cream but the flavor of the dough was missing something. The crumb buns were horrible. The breads were OK. It's not what it used to be but it's not bad either. Some things are better than others and some prices are a little steep. Miss the hustle and bustle of the shelf-filled, overcrowded Gerst's.

3
★★★☆☆

Maybe I'm spoiled but growing up with Gerst's was an incredibly wonderful memory. Moved away 18 yrs ago and got to go back last week. On top of my list was a shopping spree at Gerst's, now Fehn's. I read reviews before I went and was concerned but decided to try it anyway. Apple Strudel was good but at $9 per LB it better be. I've had better. Irish soda bread had way too much fennel seed and the rest of it was nothing special. The donuts had a good amount of jelly and cream but the flavor of the dough was missing something. The crumb buns were horrible. The breads were OK. It's not what it used to be but it's not bad either. Some things are better than others and some prices are a little steep. Miss the hustle and bustle of the shelf-filled, overcrowded Gerst's.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

Me and my husband were new in the area and everytime we passed by we always wanted to give it a try... finally one day we did (we were craving rainbow cookies)... everything look and smell good but the girl in the counter was so rude that we didnt even stay to buy nothing we ended up buying from an italian bakery two blocks away ... this def shows that even if your product is the best in the area, customer service is def what will bring costumers back to your store...

1
★☆☆☆☆

Me and my husband were new in the area and everytime we passed by we always wanted to give it a try... finally one day we did (we were craving rainbow cookies)... everything look and smell good but the girl in the counter was so rude that we didnt even stay to buy nothing we ended up buying from an italian bakery two blocks away ... this def shows that even if your product is the best in the area, customer service is def what will bring costumers back to your store...

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

For the longest time, we got our birthday cakes her for all family birthdays, and they were really something to look forward to, but for some reason, not dissatisfaction with Fehn's, we switched to ice cream cakes. But, still, every year, my neighbor gets me a cookie tray from here, as she knows how much I love this shop. Highly recommend.

5
★★★★★

For the longest time, we got our birthday cakes her for all family birthdays, and they were really something to look forward to, but for some reason, not dissatisfaction with Fehn's, we switched to ice cream cakes. But, still, every year, my neighbor gets me a cookie tray from here, as she knows how much I love this shop. Highly recommend.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I remember growing up knowing the original Gerst Bakery here. The lady who owns it now has made it even better. I went in on Sat. and found rice rolls and old fashion white mountin rolls. The place is a wonder and they best part is there is enough help to get you in and out without lines.

2
★★★★★

I remember growing up knowing the original Gerst Bakery here. The lady who owns it now has made it even better. I went in on Sat. and found rice rolls and old fashion white mountin rolls. The place is a wonder and they best part is there is enough help to get you in and out without lines.

Pros: Great pastries, outstanding rolls

Cons: parking is tough

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Fehn's Cake & Cookie Shop, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review