Coch, Reilly, Md - Guthrie Medical Group

★★☆☆☆
  • 1780 Hanshaw Road

    Ithaca, NY 14850

    Map & Directions
  • 607-257-5858

About Coch, Reilly, Md - Guthrie Medical Group

2.125 8
Hi! Sign in to let us know how Coch, Reilly, Md - Guthrie Medical Group was?
Write a Review
.

This physician is great. I have been going to him for several years and I have found him to be a young enthusiastic and knowledgeable modern physician. I thoroughly research all of the medical issues that I have (and I've had several substantial issues) and Coch is always spot on with his recommendations, treatments, etc. I also recently (randomly) met an older gentleman in Ithaca that told me that Coch had saved his life after a few years of poor treatment by another doctor. In my book, he's excellent.

4
★★★★☆

This physician is great. I have been going to him for several years and I have found him to be a young enthusiastic and knowledgeable modern physician. I thoroughly research all of the medical issues that I have (and I've had several substantial issues) and Coch is always spot on with his recommendations, treatments, etc. I also recently (randomly) met an older gentleman in Ithaca that told me that Coch had saved his life after a few years of poor treatment by another doctor. In my book, he's excellent.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I honestly cannot believe the reviews above are genuine...they seem to be written about another doctor all together. My family and I moved to Ithaca a few years ago...we have four young children. When we moved here, we asked around about local Pediatricians and heard nothing but good things about Dr. Coch. We've been taking our kids to him since then and couldn't be happier. He is knowledgeable, caring, and really treats our children as if they were his own. The staff and front desk at his office are friendly and always remember us when we come in. The nurses are fantastic with my boys...they can be tough for most to handle. A friend of mine found these reviews after I suggested she take her kids to his office...she's since been to see Dr. Coch and agrees...he is one of the best pediatricians in town.

5
★★★★★

I honestly cannot believe the reviews above are genuine...they seem to be written about another doctor all together. My family and I moved to Ithaca a few years ago...we have four young children. When we moved here, we asked around about local Pediatricians and heard nothing but good things about Dr. Coch. We've been taking our kids to him since then and couldn't be happier. He is knowledgeable, caring, and really treats our children as if they were his own. The staff and front desk at his office are friendly and always remember us when we come in. The nurses are fantastic with my boys...they can be tough for most to handle. A friend of mine found these reviews after I suggested she take her kids to his office...she's since been to see Dr. Coch and agrees...he is one of the best pediatricians in town.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

This man almost killed me in the hospital. I entered with simple vomiting and he not only gave me a dangerous combination of drugs, but also completely removed me from regular medications that I've taken for past 15 years. Result? I went into a countless number of painful seizures, lost 25 lbs. in one week, and could not walk. He discharged me still vomiting, unable to walk and with the diagnosis that "there was nothing physically wrong with me." Insult to Injury: in the hospital he lied, saying he had consulted with my doctor about removing me from existing medications. Post-hospital I talked with my doctor and she was never even notified that there was anything wrong with me. Dangerous Guy- keep away if you like life!!

3
★★★☆☆

This man almost killed me in the hospital. I entered with simple vomiting and he not only gave me a dangerous combination of drugs, but also completely removed me from regular medications that I've taken for past 15 years. Result? I went into a countless number of painful seizures, lost 25 lbs. in one week, and could not walk. He discharged me still vomiting, unable to walk and with the diagnosis that "there was nothing physically wrong with me." Insult to Injury: in the hospital he lied, saying he had consulted with my doctor about removing me from existing medications. Post-hospital I talked with my doctor and she was never even notified that there was anything wrong with me. Dangerous Guy- keep away if you like life!!

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

This doctor is rude, condescending, and down right mean. I would recommend you stay as far away as possible! He demonstrated an unwillingness to listen to my concerns as a patient. He stated that my prescriptions were an inconvenience to his staff. When I questioned the ethics of making a decision about my health based upon his staff's level of convenience - he then stated that my combination of medications created a potential lawsuit. When I went to a qualified doctor after a particularly horrible office visit, I asked about the lawsuit potential - she stated there was no way their practice would be liable even if I brought the suit. He is an absolutely horrible doctor.

1
★☆☆☆☆

This doctor is rude, condescending, and down right mean. I would recommend you stay as far away as possible! He demonstrated an unwillingness to listen to my concerns as a patient. He stated that my prescriptions were an inconvenience to his staff. When I questioned the ethics of making a decision about my health based upon his staff's level of convenience - he then stated that my combination of medications created a potential lawsuit. When I went to a qualified doctor after a particularly horrible office visit, I asked about the lawsuit potential - she stated there was no way their practice would be liable even if I brought the suit. He is an absolutely horrible doctor.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

The reason I went there was because it was easy getting an appointment. But after that even after several visits there was no diagnosis. Doctor suggested me doing a Google search for my problems!!! Dont go here for anything more than a common cold.

1
★☆☆☆☆

The reason I went there was because it was easy getting an appointment. But after that even after several visits there was no diagnosis. Doctor suggested me doing a Google search for my problems!!! Dont go here for anything more than a common cold.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

This place is a disaster.

I found one single member of the office staff who was competent and agreeable (Carrie). The rest of my interactions with the office staff were very negative. I often felt like I was an annoyance, and was often treated in an exceedingly rude and condascending manner. I frequently had to make several phone calls to get a single issue addressed (let alone resolved).

1
★☆☆☆☆

This place is a disaster.

I found one single member of the office staff who was competent and agreeable (Carrie). The rest of my interactions with the office staff were very negative. I often felt like I was an annoyance, and was often treated in an exceedingly rude and condascending manner. I frequently had to make several phone calls to get a single issue addressed (let alone resolved).

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

I had heard good things about this practice, but
after seeing several different physicians I can't
say much to recommend visiting the office for
medical care unless it is an emergency. The
front desk staff are disorganized and do not
go out of their way to answer questions. The
doctors don't inspire confidence, especially
when they won't admit they don't know what
they're doing, but try to treat symptoms anyway.
There are better general practices in the area
to seek medical care.

1
★☆☆☆☆

I had heard good things about this practice, but
after seeing several different physicians I can't
say much to recommend visiting the office for
medical care unless it is an emergency. The
front desk staff are disorganized and do not
go out of their way to answer questions. The
doctors don't inspire confidence, especially
when they won't admit they don't know what
they're doing, but try to treat symptoms anyway.
There are better general practices in the area
to seek medical care.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

.

The only good things that can be said for this "medicine mill" is that they take most forms of insurance and they are fairly easy to get an appointment with. Beyond that, there is nothing to recommend. Their physicians seem like they would be lucky to get a job in a third world clinic. Anything more complex than the common cold might be better diagnosed out of an at-home medical symptom text. Really, it's simply amazing, especially when you take into account that Guthrie is part of the medical conglomerate owning Robert Packer Hospital in Sayre, PA, a genuinely good facility in a medically mediocore area.

1
★☆☆☆☆

The only good things that can be said for this "medicine mill" is that they take most forms of insurance and they are fairly easy to get an appointment with. Beyond that, there is nothing to recommend. Their physicians seem like they would be lucky to get a job in a third world clinic. Anything more complex than the common cold might be better diagnosed out of an at-home medical symptom text. Really, it's simply amazing, especially when you take into account that Guthrie is part of the medical conglomerate owning Robert Packer Hospital in Sayre, PA, a genuinely good facility in a medically mediocore area.

Was this review helpful to you?
Ratings_icons Ratings_icons

 

Wait, you're the expert.

If you've been to or used Coch, Reilly, Md - Guthrie Medical Group, leave a review.

It's easy, only takes a couple of minutes and you'll help thousands make an informed decision.



Write a Review