This place totally reminds me of a 50's classic dinner! I feel like the only thing missing are servers on rollerskates! The best part of Jimmy's is the service. The manager led us to a secret garden in East Harlem where we could enjoy our burgers (great) and grilled cheese (even better)! Though you may not be offered the garden, the food is worth it.
I think this place has got to have the best burgers on the island. The 1900 hundred burger is always cooked to order, with extra cheese (if you've ordered cheese) and dripping with taste. The steak fries are an amazing addition to the burger. But the winner is the cole slaw and pickles that they serve as a starter. The cole slaw is out of this world and the garlic pickles will have you asking for me!! A must if you are in this sleepy town of Patchogue!
I disagree with the reviews that this place is out of this world! These people need to visit the city! The food here was mediocre at best with mediocre service and a high bill at the end of the evening. One of my guests had the fish and it was gritty and not fresh. Another guest had the extremely soft and tasteless gnocchi and my lasagna was hardly anything to rave about! Drinks and wine were expensive too!
Peter's luncheonette is the best place to go for breakfast in Medford! The staff is friendly, fast and efficient and the food is delicious! Even dinner is great! Lots of food for inexpensive prices!
Howard's has the best deal on Long Island. At least I think it is! Unlimited beer with a burger or sandwich! How can you go wrong? I love the sliced steak sandwich with mozzarella on garlic bread. It comes with a salad and your choice of dressing. They bring it right over to the table! This place is great! Come early or late, because it gets packed!
This is the best Greek food in this town. The hummus is amazing, as are the gyros and the vegetable platter. The service isn't that great, but you will forget it when the food comes!
I used to go here for lunch as a senior in high school! In fact, most of us did! We didn't know any better! The pizza is average and the bagels are really doughy. If that is what you like than stop here!
Seriously, I have been going here since I was a kid with a paperroute! I paid for the bagels and cream cheese with my change! They have the best twists and speciality cream cheese. This place always has a line out the door every morning! IF you are visiting this small town, definitely visit here for the best bagels in town!
If you think this is a great steakhouse then there is something wrong with you! You haven't been to the city! This place pales in comparison to some of the great steakhouses: del Friscos, Morton's, Peter Luger's! Don't waste your time here. The food is sub par and feels like a chain experience!!!
This is about the only place to go to in Patchogue when the weather is beautiful! The food is good (try the marinated burger or steaks!), though the prices are too high for the area. You make up for it with the landscape: the views of the bay and the boats are worth it. Definitely a place to check out if you are in the area.