Highland Tap
This is a good bar in the Highlands. The person who said that you feel like you're in a cavern is very right. It's a neat atmosphere, but it also gets really smoky down there. I've heard that the burgers are great, but I've never eaten there.
Cafe di Sol
The atmosphere here is fun and it's perfect for a group. The drinks are very good and the food is great too. There's an interesting mix of menus items.
Fontaine's Oyster House
I've only come here for the bar, but I've enjoyed it. It's a very narrow space, so it's hard to move around, but if you can get out ont he back patio then it's great.
San Francisco Coffee Roasting Co.
This is one of my favorite coffee shops. They have free wifi, so when the weather is nice I love sitting on the back patio and doing work. The coffee is great too.
Shout
The food here is so so. I went a while back and the sushi was pretty good, but I went recently and had a sandwich that was nothing spectacular. I would go back for the patio, but probably not for the food.
Aurora Coffee
This is a great little coffee shop in the heart of the Highlands. The coffee is great and the atmosphere is nice. It has all the drinks that you would expect from a coffee shop.
Gumby's Pizza
The Pokey sticks are amazing! This place is packed late at night, but there's a reason. It's a great place to grab some food after a night out in Tallahassee.
Sweetwaters Coffee & Tea Plymouth Green
This is a great coffee shop! They have a good variety of drinks and food. The atmosphere is great as well. I would definitely come here regularly if I lived in the area.
Zingerman's Delicatessen
Zingerman's is notorious for its sandwiches and it lives up to the hype. They variety and quality of the sandwiches is great. There's also plenty of seating.
Il Mulino Restaurant
This is a very upscale Italian restaurant. I went during restaurant week and really enjoyed it, but I don't think I'd go if I had to pay full price. They give you lots of "free items" before you order your appetizers and everything was great.