1-10 of 100

Pizza Restaurants - East Setauket, NY

★★★★★ 2 Reviews

Via Pizza & Pasta, Etc.

  • 205 Rte 25A, East Setauket, NY
  • 631-689-9540

"My family and i order pizza from Via most Friday nights. The service is exceptional, and they always remember who we are. When we walk in the door, ..."

★★★★★ 24 Reviews

Little Vincent's Pizza Restaurant

  • 324 Smithtown Blvd, Lake Ronkonkoma, NY
  • 631-981-9631

"I found a place called Little Vincents Pizza Restaurant. This place is cool, they are open long hours. It is a great place to stay with, if you ..."

★★★★☆ 11 Reviews


  • 555 Route 111, Hauppauge, NY
  • 631-724-6663

"I love this place. Each time I dine here the food has been excellent and well prepared. Lots of food too! Their chicken parm is enough to feed ..."

★★★★★ 5 Reviews

O Sole Mio

  • 2194 Nesconset Hwy C, Stony Brook, NY
  • 631-751-1600

"Every time we make pizza at home, we get the dough from here. They also have a ton of great different types of pizzas and pinwheels. A++"

★★★★★ 4 Reviews


  • 243 N Country Rd, Smithtown, NY
  • 631-928-4972

"This place is hands down the best. They have some of the most fantastic pizza I've ever had. There's a nice seating area in the back where you ..."

★★★★★ 4 Reviews

Joe's Pizza

  • 346 Union Ave, Holbrook, NY
  • 631-981-3029

"I've always had a good experience at Joe's! If you're in the mood for a great pizza, Joe's is the place to go! The service, hospitality and food ..."

★★★★★ 8 Reviews

Carnival Restaurant

  • 4900 Nesconset Hwy, Port Jefferson Station, NY
  • 631-473-9772

"Considering I work there the roach comment is a LIE!!.....inexperienced staff ? Nick would NEVER stand for it!!.....pick up orders are pretty clear.....wait at the PICK UP LINE!"

★★★★☆ 8 Reviews

Matt's Pizza

  • 348 Lake Ave Ste 3, ST JAMES, NY
  • 631-862-6161

"Been a loyal customer for years but it is time to venture out and try others. My last 2 experiences were not good. Last week I ordered a ..."

★★★★☆ 8 Reviews

Colosseo Pizza & Restaurant

  • 1049 Rte 112, Port Jeffrsn Sta, NY
  • 631-928-4972

"Absolute favorite pizza ever! I grew up in Port Jefferson, and I moved away about 3 years ago, and I frequently make the 30 minute trip JUST to ..."

★★★★☆ 7 Reviews

Momma Lombardi's

  • 400 Furrows Rd, Holbrook, NY
  • 631-737-0774

"Best Italian food you'll ever find. Huge portions, best veal I ever had. They make their own pasta there too. You'll never get better Italian food anywhere. Try ..."

Related East Setauket, NY searches